Better Together – How were the options developed?

16 November 2026

Powys Teaching Health Board is inviting people across Powys to help shape the future of local NHS services.

The consultation runs from 5 October 2026 to 10 January 2027 and seeks views on proposals for adult physical health, adult mental health, urgent care and some diagnostic services.

Thirteen locality events and three online events provide opportunities for people to meet the team, ask questions, discuss the proposals and then complete the questionnaire. Full details can be found at http://pthb.nhs.wales/BetterTogether

The latest in our series of regular Better Together articles explains how the options for the future of health services in Powys were developed.

You can read the Full Consultation Document on our website or find out more by reading the "Developing options for the future" chapter below.

This chapter explains how options for the future were identified and assessed. It explains the evidence, engagement activities and evaluation used to develop the options and explains why some ideas were taken forward while others were not.

The options included in this consultation are the result of a structured and evidence-based process designed to ensure that all realistic possibilities were considered and tested before being reviewed through this period of public consultation. The process we have followed adopts good practice guidance from across public services. It also reflects national policy and legislation including Welsh Government guidance on NHS Wales service changes.

Throughout the process, options were shaped by what people told us, informed by clinical and professional expertise, assessed against agreed criteria, and subjected to independent challenge and assurance. This chapter explains the process we followed. The following Chapters explain what this means for each service area: Adult Physical Health (Chapter 6), Urgent Care (Chapter 7), Adult Mental Health (Chapter 8).


A Five-Step Process

The Health Board followed a five-step process to develop the Better Together consultation options.  The approach was designed to ensure that all options were assessed consistently, fairly and transparently, while remaining focused on the issues identified in the Case For Change.

The five steps were:

  • Understanding the Need for Change.
  • Generating Ideas and Exploring Possibilities.
  • Reviewing and Refining Draft Options.
  • Development of a Shortlist.
  • Appraisal, Assurance and Preparation for Consultation.

Taken together, these steps created a clear line of sight from the challenges facing services through to the options now being consulted on.


Step 1: Understanding the Need for Change

The first step focused on developing and testing the Case For Change.

The Case For Change brought together evidence about the challenges facing health care services in Powys, including workforce shortages, increasing demand, changing population needs, health inequalities, difficulties accessing services and the pressures associated with delivering services across a large rural county.

The Health Board undertook extensive engagement with patients, residents, staff, partners and stakeholders to test whether the Case For Change reflected their experiences and understanding of local services. This helped ensure that the issues identified accurately reflected what matters to local people and those delivering services.

Alongside this engagement, clinicians, service leads, service user representatives and colleagues from partner organisations have worked together on a wide range of tasks including developing future models of care, design principles, travel time principles and assessment criteria that would later be used to guide and assess potential options. These principles established a consistent framework for the entire options development process.

Every future option needed to demonstrate how it would address the challenges set out within the Case for Change.

More information about engagement on the Case For Change is available from the Better Together website at pthb.nhs.wales/BetterTogether. You can also read the Case For Change and a series of Technical Chapters.


Step 2: Generating Ideas and Exploring Possibilities

The second step focused on generating possible solutions.

Due to the rurality of Powys, when we design services, we need to consider how best to deliver them in our rural environment. This helps us assess whether the right amount of patient activity is being delivered at each level in order to maintain the skills and capabilities of health care staff. If they see too few patients needing specific treatment they may lose their skills, and could lose their professional accreditation to offer this service.

The following design principles helped clinicians consider whether services can be provided in your home, in your locality, within Powys at a regional level, or need to be provided outside the county. We have used these principles to shape the options in this consultation:

  • Level: Home
  • Description:
    • Some services can be delivered safely and effectively in people’s homes. This includes health care staff who visit you to provide services at home. It also includes online and telephone services, as well as tools to help you manage your own care at home.
  • Level: Locality / Community (e.g. communities of around 10,000 people)
  • Description:
    • Some services can be provided locally within the community you live in. For example, GP primary care services are provided in all 13 localities in Powys.
    • The 13 localities in Powys are Brecon, Builth & Llanwrtyd, Crickhowell, Hay & Talgarth, Knighton & Presteigne, Llandrindod & Rhayader, Llanfair Caereinion, Llanfyllin, Llanidloes, Machynlleth, Newtown, Welshpool & Montgomery, Ystradgynlais.
  • Level: “Powys Region” or “Cluster”
  • Description:
    • Some services need to be provided at a “regional” level within Powys. They may need specialist equipment and staff that are best provided in a single location serving a larger population but this could be from more than one location within Powys.
    • For example, we currently provide day surgery and endoscopy in Brecon and Llandrindod Wells. We also have an ambition to day surgery and endoscopy services in Newtown in future as part of the North Powys Wellbeing programme. These services are outside the scope of the current consultation but provide examples of what we mean by “Powys Region”
  • Level: “Once for Powys”
  • Description:
    • Some services can safely be delivered within the county, but because they are much more specialised in nature they may need to be provided from one location or by one centralised team.
    • For example, Felindre Ward in Bronllys is currently our adult (18-64) mental health admissions unit for functional mental health conditions
  • Level: Outside the county
  • Description:
    • The rural and sparsely populated nature of Powys means that some services cannot be safely delivered within the county due to their highly specialised nature.
    • For example, we access District General Hospital services in neighbouring counties in both England and Wales

Ideas came from multiple sources including:

  • Public and stakeholder engagement.
  • Clinical and professional workshops.
  • Service reviews.
  • Technical analysis.
  • Feedback from partners and staff.
  • Deliberative events involving patients, service users and community representatives.

Through this process, a wide range of ideas were identified and reviewed. These ideas ranged from service improvements and new ways of working through to more transformational changes in how and where services could be delivered.

To help test different approaches, the Health Board developed six scenarios describing broad ways services could be organised in the future. These scenarios were not detailed service proposals and were not intended to become consultation options. Instead, they were used to stimulate discussion and gather views about different directions of travel.

These were:

  • No change.
  • Minor changes and developments to the way we provide physical and mental health community services.
  • More services provided within “centres of excellence” including in Rural Regional Centres. This would mean that some of our services (such as hospital beds) would be provided in fewer locations than now. 
  • Developing and expanding the range of services available at home through strengthened primary and community teams.
  • Inpatient care, including community hospital beds, is provided outside the county in neighbouring health boards.
  • Provide a District General Hospital in Powys.

“No Change” and “Provide a District General Hospital in Powys” were included for comparison purposes. The Case For Change had demonstrated that “No Change” is not an option, and there are no safe or viable options for providing a District General Hospital in Powys.

Engagement on these scenarios helped identify:

  • The characteristics people most wanted to see in future services.
  • Views about the balance between local access and service sustainability.
  • Attitudes towards greater integration of services.
  • Support for strengthening care in community settings.
  • Concerns about travel and access in a rural county 

The outputs from this stage helped shape the long list of options that would move forward for more detailed consideration.

More information about engagement on the scenarios and what we heard is available from the Supporting Documents section of our website. You can also find detailed information about the range of ideas in our Step Report which is also available from the Supporting Documents section of our website


Steps 3 and 4: Reviewing and Refining Draft Options and Developing a Shortlist 

When we review health services we use “hurdle criteria” to help us decide which options to focus on. The “hurdle criteria” are key tests (“hurdles”) that options must pass before they are given further consideration. This helps us to ensure that we do not spend time and public money testing options that would not work. 

For the Better Together programme we identified five Hurdle Criteria. These were influenced by the feedback we heard through staff and public engagement.

  • Criterion: Is the potential solution clinically sustainable?
  • Explanation:
    • Does it deliver progress towards safe and reliable services that meet quality standards?
    • Does it consider any co-dependencies (the way in which different services need to work together)?
    • Is it informed by evidence ensuring people receive the right care and optimal outcomes?
  • Criterion: Does the potential solution improve access?
  • Explanation:
    • Does it enable people to access advice, guidance and care quickly and easily?
    • Does it address equity of access?
    • Does it provide access within an appropriate timeframe?
  • Criterion: Is the potential solution deliverable?
  • Explanation:
    • Is the workforce or an alternative workforce model available to deliver it?
    • Has digital technology been considered in the development of the solution?
    • Will it be clinically deliverable in a short (1-2 years), medium (2-4 years) or long (5-10 years) timeframe?
    • Will it be operationally deliverable in a short (1-2 years), medium (2-4 years) or long (5-10 years) timeframe?
  • Criterion: Does the potential solution support (or at least not contradict) …
  • Explanation:
    • ... a person centred care system that meets people’s needs?
    • ... integrated working with partners?
    • ... improvement of population health?
    • ... the strategic direction for Powys (e.g. Health and Care Strategy, PTHB strategic priorities) and for NHS Wales (e.g. A Healthier Wales)?
  • Criterion: Is the potential solution financially sustainable?
  • Explanation:
    • Does it make best use of financial resources in the short and long term?
    • Does it support a value-based approach to improve outcomes?
    • Does it improve efficiency and productivity and reduce waste?

From Long List to Short List

Each option was reviewed against the Hurdle Criteria.

Options that failed one or more of the criteria were removed from further consideration. Similar options were merged, refined or incorporated into broader proposals where appropriate. Feedback from engagement, deliberative events and clinical challenge sessions also informed decisions about which options should progress.

In total:

  • 81 options were assessed through the hurdling process.
  • 43 options were discounted.
  • 38 options progressed for further consideration in Step 5.

Detailed information about the long list of ideas and how they were appraised can be found in the Step Report which is available from the Supporting Documents section of our website.


Step 5: Appraisal, Assurance and Preparation for Consultation

Once the shortlist had been established, each option underwent a comprehensive programme of technical assessment and assurance.

This included:

  • Workforce modelling.
  • Financial appraisal.
  • Estates assessment.
  • Demand and capacity modelling.
  • Travel time analysis.
  • Patient pathway testing.
  • Equality, quality and other impact assessments.
  • Clinical challenge and review.

The purpose of this work was to understand the advantages, disadvantages, risks and impacts associated with each option. 

We published draft Assessment Criteria in June 2025 and asked for feedback from patients, the public, staff and partner organisations. We have updated the Assessment Criteria in response to the views that we heard. These criteria use the six domains of quality in the NHS Wales Health and Care Quality Standards.

  • Quality Domain: Safe
  • Examples:
    • Supports safe clinical practice.
    • Ensures a substantive workforce model.
    • Improves staff safety including a culture of safety and speaking up safely.
  • Quality Domain: Timely
  • Examples:
    • Delivers against required access standards.
    • Improves access to services that support people to stay at home where possible and enables timely response when needs escalate.
    • Enables efficient transfer and discharge pathways to prevent harm to patients.
  • Quality Domain: Effective
  • Examples:
    • Is underpinned by reliable data, best practice guidance and evidence base.
    • Supports delivery of future models of care, national and local guidance.
    • Addresses existing barriers to care in the case for change such as continuity of care and communication.
  • Quality Domain: Efficient
  • Examples:
    • Makes best use of resources to improve patient outcomes and experience, and staff satisfaction, and enables us to live within our means.
    • Uses digital technology to aid efficient care with consideration for those not able to use technology.
    • Is feasible and can achieve a positive impact within the short or medium term.
  • Quality Domain: Equitable
  • Example:
    • Delivers evidence-based care across Powys but can adapt to address differences in need positively contributing towards reducing health inequity.
    • Reduces inequity across Powys for example through removing unnecessary differences in the way services are delivered.
    • Delivers an appropriate offer for all population groups including those with protected characteristics.
  • Quality Domain: Person-Centred
  • Example:
    • Helps people to stay healthy and builds self-reliance in patients and the population.
    • Provides a responsive joined-up offer that supports people to achieve what matters most to them and improves patient experience outcomes
    • Provides access to meet health care needs within acceptable travel times (in line with the evidence base).

Each option was scored against these criteria using an agreed scoring system.

Weightings were applied to reflect strategic priorities. Sensitivity analysis was undertaken to test whether results changed significantly under different assumptions. This provided additional assurance that the findings were robust and that no single criterion disproportionately influenced the outcome of the assessment process.

The appraisal results formed one part of the wider decision-making process and were considered alongside workforce, financial, estates, travel, quality and equality assessments.

Independent Challenge and Assurance

Independent challenge and assurance were embedded throughout the process.

Three deliberative events brought together patients, communities, staff, local authorities, voluntary organisations, primary care representatives and other stakeholders to test and refine emerging proposals throughout the process. These events provided an important opportunity to challenge assumptions, explore risks and ensure the developing options reflected the issues and priorities identified by local communities.

External experts provided advice and review in areas such as service redesign, patient pathway testing, demand and capacity modelling and clinical service transformation. Independent engagement and consultation specialists provided advice on the design of the engagement process and on consultation readiness.

The programme also included a number of formal assurance mechanisms, including:

  • Review by the clinical members of the Executive Committee.
  • Workforce and Finance Check and Challenge sessions.
  • Independent consultation assurance.

Arriving at the Consultation Options

The options now presented within this consultation are the outcome of this structured process.

Many more possibilities were considered during the development phase. Some were discounted because they did not meet the Hurdle Criteria. Others were combined or refined as evidence developed and stakeholder feedback was received. The options that remain are those that the Health Board considers to be viable and capable of addressing the challenges set out in the Case For Change.

Importantly, no final decisions have been made.

The purpose of this consultation is to seek views on these options, understand the impacts they may have on patients, communities, staff and partners, and ensure that consultation feedback informs future decision-making. Any final decision will only be taken after consultation responses have been fully considered.

What Happens Next?

The next chapters describe the options in more detail, including what each option would mean in practice, the potential benefits, the risks and trade-offs that have been identified, and the matters on which we are particularly seeking your views.


Further Information

Further information on the options development process and how we arrived at the final list of options is available in the Step Report and in the Pre-Consultation Business Case. These are available from the Supporting Documents section of our website.